WALNUT CREEK, CA — Dan’s Irish Sports Bar has poured pints at 1524 Civic Drive for more than 55 years.

The man who owns it now thinks that run could end in a courtroom. Or on some other block, if the fight goes the wrong way.

The short answer on closing

There is no closure date. No farewell party on the calendar, no countdown taped to the register. The bar is open tonight.

Owner Saul Tallarico isn’t pretending otherwise. He puts the odds low.

“Who are we if we’re not human, if we don’t hold out hope for some sort of Hail Mary?” he told NBC Bay Area.

Advertisement placeholder on Mayor of Walnut Creek

He answered his own question a moment later. “Is that the likelihood? Probably not,” he said. “That’s why I’m looking at other spaces.”

The lease is the thing in question, not the taps.

What Tallarico says happened

Tallarico started behind the bar at Dan’s in 1996. He bought the place in 2011.

His account of the last several months is straightforward. He negotiated to renew the lease in good faith. The terms moved underneath him anyway.

Then came the ask, as he describes it: an extra $500,000 on top of rent, to match an offer from a competing tenant.

He didn’t write the check. Instead, Tallarico filed civil litigation in Contra Costa County against the property manager, the landlord, and that competing tenant.

NBC contacted all three for comment. None of them responded. Neither the tenant nor the property manager has been publicly named, so the other side of this story is still a blank page.

Fifty-five years on one corner

Dan’s has held that corner since long before downtown looked like downtown.

Civic Drive back then was a quieter stretch, the kind of street where a pub settles in for decades and nobody thinks twice. The wood on the bar is worn smooth in exactly the spots you’d expect. The TVs run a beat behind the game, and nobody minds.

Interior of a traditional Irish sports bar in Walnut Creek
A room that earns a nickname like “our Cheers” and keeps it. Photo: Da Mayor.

Around it, the blocks keep reshuffling.

More homes are going up where a parking lot used to sit. A homegrown name came back to North Main the same season a national chain pulled out of a strip mall down the road.

The churn is the story. Dan’s has mostly watched it happen from behind the bar. Some afternoons it feels like the last thing on this block that has not moved.

The room on a Saturday

Word got around fast, the way it does in a town this size.

Bartender Alona Lettner told NBC that people have been dropping in for weeks, and her pitch is not subtle. “Come visit us while we’re still here, come in, take your pictures.”

They came on a recent Saturday, filling the room with regulars who have ordered here since they were old enough to drink.

Patrick Yang of Concord is one of them. “I think we’ve all met a lot of our good friends here,” he said. “We’ve celebrated many birthdays.”

“This is our local ‘Cheers.’”

— Brittany Grinnel, Walnut Creek resident

Brittany Grinnel used the line every beloved bar eventually earns. Then she said the part that lands harder than last call.

If Dan’s goes, she goes. “I’ll move out of Walnut Creek,” she said. “Walnut Creek is becoming way too commercial.”

The commercial question

That complaint gets waved off around here. It’s the reflex of anyone who has stayed in one place long enough to watch it change.

On Civic Drive it is less abstract.

A lease that once fit a neighborhood pub now gets priced against what a national tenant will pay. That’s how the $500,000 figure reads, if Tallarico’s account holds up.

Whether it holds is for a judge. What isn’t in dispute is the arithmetic of the corner. A bar that has traded there for 55 years is being asked to outbid the market for its own address.

What the competing tenant intends to do with the space isn’t public. Neither is the rent anyone else was willing to sign.

The Dan’s File

  • Where: 1524 Civic Drive, Walnut Creek CA 94596
  • On this corner: more than 55 years
  • Owner since 2011: Saul Tallarico, behind the bar since 1996
  • The ask: $500,000 more than rent, per the owner
  • Status: civil litigation filed in Contra Costa County
  • Closure date: none announced
  • Phone: (925) 932-1331

What happens next

The case moves at the speed civil cases move, which is not the speed a bar can plan around.

Meanwhile Tallarico is doing two jobs. Two jobs, one guy. The doors stay open on Civic Drive, and he is also scouting other Walnut Creek addresses with the staff in mind.

“Doors will be open here as long as we can keep them open,” he said. “And then hopefully we find this next place, and this next place will be the next magical spot.”

That’s the plan. It depends on a lease, a landlord, and a market that hasn’t been kind. Ask anyone who has signed a renewal downtown lately.

If you want one more round

Dan’s is open at 1524 Civic Drive, a short walk from the Walnut Creek BART platform and a block off North Main.

Hours run late for downtown. Patch lists Sunday service from 11 a.m. to 2 a.m., with the full sports schedule spread across the TVs.

Parking is the usual downtown puzzle. The city garages stay free for the first hours, which is the cheap way to make a night of it.

Call (925) 932-1331 before you drive over.

Da Mayor’s Take

A bar isn’t a tenant category. Dan’s has been the room where this town celebrates things for 55 years, and lease math doesn’t care about that. Go in, order something, tip the bartender.

Whatever the judge does, the corner is already different.

Fifty-five years is a long run for any business. Expecting a landlord to price sentiment into a lease is unreasonable. Asking a neighborhood that keeps getting nicer to do it is stranger still.

Which leaves the part nobody can litigate: the regulars, the worn wood, the TVs a beat behind the game.

Know something I should cover? Reply or DM.